Lacks transparency. Publishes some details, but doesn't show its workers are paid and treated fairly.
Last researched 23 October 2026 · 10 sources
Australian frozen fish and seafood brand of Simplot Australia.
Until I&J traces its fish and seafood to the boat or farm and has the conditions of the people who catch or farm it checked independently, it can't show that they are free and fairly paid.
Know something we've missed? Send evidence. Represent I&J? Send a right of reply.
Compare I&J with another brand
Why it's graded Lacks transparency
- Not met: Meets 1 of 6 Good requirements.
- Holds the grade back: It relies on fish and seafood that it can't trace to the boat or farm. That alone means a poor grade until it takes steps to trace it and check the conditions of the people who catch or farm it.
- It isn't Harm on record: the most serious problem on its record (forced labour link, last recorded in 2023) was a link through a supplier, which the company has acted on.
- Lacks transparency is still a poor grade: in supply chains like this, workers who can't be seen to be treated fairly are usually underpaid or unprotected.
- Checks its own supply chain. I&J looks for problems in its own supply chain and publishes what it finds. It found forced labour in 2023 and is fixing it, so it doesn't count against the grade. It's listed below under Confirmed issues.
Good requirements 1 of 6
- Not met: Pays a living wage, or holds a strong fair-pay certificationLiving wage: no evidence
- Not met: Respects worker rightsSome of its products are made in countries such as Thailand and China, where unions are heavily restricted, and it has no full supply chain audit.
- Not met: Supply chain independently audited or certified, or at least 80% made in countries with strong labour standards
- Met: No child or forced labour findings it isn't fixingIts own checks found forced labour, which it is fixing. That's listed below and doesn't count against the grade. An unconfirmed report of forced labour is listed below. It doesn't affect the grade.
- Not met: Names the factories or farms that make its products, or is fully certified by a scheme that holds and audits that list
- Not met: Traces its catch to the boat or farm and has crews' or farm workers' conditions checked independently
Red flags 3
- Red flag: No evidence it pays a living wage
- Red flag: Made partly in countries with poor worker rights, without a full independent audit of its supply chain
- Red flag: Relies on fish and seafood it can't trace to the boat or farm
- Red flag: Fails its category's raw-material check (means Lacks transparency)
Stars it would earn as Good
None yet. Stars only show on Good companies. About stars
Where it's made
I&J says it makes products in Thailand. Simplot Australia's figures name New Zealand, Poland and Taiwan. Product labels show Australia, China and Vietnam. The rest is shown as where fish and seafood are usually processed.
| Country | Worker rights | Legal minimum wage | Forced labour risk |
|---|---|---|---|
| Thailand | No guarantee of rights | Below a living wage | Moderate |
| China | No guarantee of rights | Below a living wage | Moderate |
| Vietnam | Systematic violations | Well below a living wage | Moderate |
| Australia | Strong protections | About a living wage | Low |
| New Zealand | Strong protections | About a living wage | Low |
| Poland | Regular violations | Close to a living wage | Moderate |
| Taiwan | Strong protections | Close to a living wage | Low |
| IndonesiaUsual for the industry | No guarantee of rights | Well below a living wage | Moderate |
| IndiaUsual for the industry | No guarantee of rights | Well below a living wage | High |
| EcuadorUsual for the industry | No guarantee of rights | Well below a living wage | Moderate |
| NorwayUsual for the industry | Strong protections | About a living wage | Low |
Evidence
What we found
- Risk across the industry, not a finding about this company: fishing fleets and processing plants have some of the worst documented forced labour, including trafficked crews held at sea for years.
- Modern slavery statement
- Makes part of its range in its own factories
- Relies on fish and seafood from fishing boats and farms, where crews and farm workers, often migrants recruited into debt, have been held for months or years, beaten and denied pay, out of reach of factory audits. It hasn't shown any steps to trace its fish and seafood to the boat or farm or have the conditions of the people who catch or farm it checked, so it's graded Lacks transparency until it does.
Research notes I&J hoki and whiting are crumbed at Simplot's Kelso plant in NSW and labelled Packed in Australia, mostly from New Zealand hoki; calamari is packed in China, fish tenders are made from Vietnamese basa and coconut prawns are made in Thailand. Simplot also names seafood processing in New Zealand, Poland, Taiwan, Argentina and Namibia without saying which brand each serves. Hoki lines are MSC certified and ASC lines are growing, but no share of the range is given. No vessel or farm lists are published and no independent crew or farm worker checks are reported for I&J.
What independent sources say
| Source | Result | Details |
|---|---|---|
| Australian Modern Slavery Register | Listed | Covered by Simplot Australia's FY25 modern slavery statement, which lists seafood processing in nine countries and 122 supplier social audits. View |
| KnowTheChain | Not covered | Neither Simplot nor I&J is among the companies assessed in the 2026 KnowTheChain food and beverage benchmark. View |
Confirmed issues 1
Only confirmed problems are listed, and old ones drop off after 10 to 15 years. A problem the company has fully put right no longer counts against it, and nor does one it finds and is fixing itself. How problems are counted
| Last recorded | What happened | Made amends? |
|---|---|---|
| 2023 | Link through a supplierSimplot Australia reported that workers at a Thai seafood processing site supplying the group had been charged recruitment fees, remediated in 2023/24; the brand affected was not named. Source · search the archiveFound and being fixed by the company Not counted against the grade while the company is actively fixing it, because it found and published it itself. | YesSimplot supported the supplier to finish repaying recruitment fees to the affected workers in 2023/24. |
Unconfirmed reports
Credible reports that haven't been confirmed by a regulator, completed investigation or the company. They're shown for your information and don't affect the grade.
- The Outlaw Ocean Project (2023) named Simplot Australia as consignee of squid from a Chinese processor tied to vessels accused of illegal fishing, and Sedex flagged possible Xinjiang forced labour at a supplier; Simplot says it never bought from them. No brand was named. Source
Sources and actions
Sources 10
Show all 10 sources
- Outlaw Ocean Project - Simplot Australia correspondence · search the archive · Simplot named as consignee of a 2022 squid shipment from Rongcheng Haibo; Simplot says it never purchased from it
- 2026 KnowTheChain food and beverage benchmark · search the archive · List of companies assessed in February 2026; Simplot not included
- Simplot amends 'Made in Australia' labelling on frozen fish brands (ACCC) · search the archive · 31 I&J and other frozen fish products relabelled Packed in Australia in 2020; fish imported from NZ, US and South Africa and crumbed in Australia
- I&J New Zealand Hoki Fish Original Crumb - Woolworths · search the archive · Sold at Woolworths; labelled Packed in Australia; MSC certified hoki
- I&J Original Fish Tenders - Woolworths · search the archive · Basa fish tenders labelled Made in Vietnam
- I&J Classic South Pacific Calamari Rings - Woolworths · search the archive · Labelled Packed in China from multiple origins
- I&J Coconut Crumbed Prawns - Simplot Foodservice · search the archive · I&J vannamei prawn product with manufacturing country Thailand
- Three awards, one big commitment to sustainable seafood (Simplot Australia, 2026) · search the archive · I&J won the ASC Best Responsible Seafood Brand award for expanding ASC certification
Published by I&J or its owner
- Simplot Australia Modern Slavery Statement FY25 · search the archive · Seafood processed in Argentina, China, Namibia, NZ, Poland, Taiwan, Thailand, US and Vietnam; Kelso frozen seafood plant; 122 supplier audits
- Simplot Australia Modern Slavery Statement 2023/24 · search the archive · Supported a supplier to finalise recruitment fee remediation at a Thai seafood site; Kelso makes frozen seafood; I&J listed among brands
Company details
- Headquarters
- Australia
- Last researched
- 23 October 2026
- Cite this page
- Labour Lens, "Is I&J ethical? Labour rating", https://www.labourlens.net/brand/i-and-j, last researched 23 October 2026, accessed [date].
- Method
- Researched with AI assistance against published rules. How we check · What Lacks transparency means
Other frozen fish and seafood brands
Nothing we've rated in frozen fish and seafood is better than Lacks transparency yet.
Something missing or wrong?
Grades are opinions based on the evidence listed here. Send us evidence, or a right of reply if you represent I&J.